Garbage Disposal Do’s and Don’ts: 10 Things You Should Never Put Down Your Disposal

What a disposal can handle, what jams it, and how to fix the common problems yourself

A garbage disposal is for small amounts of soft food scraps, run with plenty of cold water. It is not a trash can, and it doesn’t have blades. It has a spinning plate with blunt lugs that fling food against a stationary grind ring until the pieces are small enough to wash out. That’s why fibrous, starchy, and hard things cause problems: they don’t grind, they wrap, paste, or jam.

Most disposal calls we get come down to one of three things: something went in that shouldn’t have, grease built up in the drain line below it, or the unit is old and the seals let go.

What can you safely put down a garbage disposal?

  • Soft fruit and vegetable scraps in small amounts.
  • Small pieces of cooked meat with no bones.
  • Cooked vegetables, bread, and other soft leftovers.
  • Citrus peels in small pieces. They help with odor.
  • Ice cubes. Good for cleaning it.

The rule for all of it: cold water on before you start, a handful at a time, and let the water run 15 to 20 seconds after the grinding sound stops so everything clears the trap.

10 things you should never put down your garbage disposal

  1. Grease, fat, and cooking oil. It goes down warm and liquid, cools in the pipe, and coats the walls. Everything after it sticks. This is the number one cause of kitchen drain clogs, disposal or not. Pour it in a can and throw it out.
  2. Coffee grounds. They don’t dissolve. They settle in the trap and pack into a dense sludge.
  3. Eggshells. The shell grinds to grit that settles in the pipe, and the membrane inside can wrap around the lugs.
  4. Fibrous vegetables: celery, corn husks, asparagus, artichokes, rhubarb, onion skins. The strings wrap around the plate and jam it.
  5. Pasta, rice, oats, and bread in quantity. They keep absorbing water after they go down and swell into a paste.
  6. Potato peels. Same problem. They turn into starchy glue.
  7. Bones and hard shells. Chicken bones, beef bones, crab and shrimp shells. They bounce around, chip the grind ring, and jam the unit.
  8. Fruit pits and popcorn kernels. Like putting a stone in it.
  9. Nuts. They grind into a peanut butter paste that sticks to the pipe.
  10. Anything that isn’t food. Twist ties, produce stickers, bottle caps, silverware, paper towels, glass, rubber bands. Also paint and chemical drain cleaners, which eat the rubber seals.

How do you fix a stinky garbage disposal?

The smell is almost always the underside of the rubber splash guard and the walls of the grind chamber, where food film builds up. Three steps:

  1. With the unit off, flip up the splash guard flaps and scrub the underside with a brush and dish soap. This alone fixes most of it.
  2. Fill the chamber with ice cubes, add a couple tablespoons of coarse salt, run cold water, and turn it on until the ice is gone. The ice scours the ring and lugs.
  3. Grind a few lemon or orange peel pieces with cold water.

Skip the baking soda and vinegar trick. It fizzes, which feels like it’s working, but it doesn’t clean anything. If the smell is coming from the drain itself rather than the disposal, it’s biofilm in the trap or the line, and that’s a drain cleaning.

Why cold water and not hot?

Cold water keeps any fat or grease solid so it gets chopped into bits and washed out. Hot water melts it, carries it farther down the line, and lets it harden there, where it’s harder to reach. Use cold when the disposal is running. Hot water down the drain afterward with a little dish soap is fine.

Disposal hums but won’t spin? Fix the jam

A hum with no spinning means the motor has power but the plate is stuck. Don’t keep hitting the switch; you’ll trip the overload or burn the motor.

  1. Turn off the switch and unplug the unit under the sink (or turn off the breaker if it’s hardwired).
  2. Look on the bottom of the disposal for a hex socket in the center. Most disposals come with a quarter-inch Allen wrench for it, and any quarter-inch Allen wrench works.
  3. Put the wrench in and work it back and forth until the plate turns freely a full rotation.
  4. With a flashlight, look down the drain for what jammed it and pull it out with tongs or pliers. Never your hand.
  5. Plug it back in, press the red reset button on the bottom, run cold water, and try it.

How long does a garbage disposal last?

Eight to twelve years is typical. Hard water shortens that a bit because scale builds up around the seals. Signs it’s on the way out:

  • You’re pressing the reset button more and more often.
  • It takes longer to grind, or you have to run it twice.
  • It trips the breaker.
  • Water in the cabinet under the sink.

Where the leak is tells you what it is. Water at the top, where the disposal meets the sink, is the mounting flange and plumber’s putty, which is a repair. Water from the side connections is a loose drain or dishwasher hose, also a repair. Water from the bottom of the unit means the internal seal has failed and the motor is getting wet. That’s a replacement, and sooner rather than later, because a wet motor is an electrical problem.

When you replace one, size it to how you cook. A 1/3 horsepower unit is fine for light use. A 1/2 horsepower is the standard for most families. If you cook a lot or have had jams, a 3/4 or 1 horsepower unit grinds finer, jams less, and runs quieter.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use chemical drain cleaners in my garbage disposal?

No. They corrode the seals and the splash guard, they rarely clear a real clog, and they can splash back out of the drain when the unit runs. If the drain is slow, it needs to be cleaned, not dissolved.

What should I do if my disposal hums but doesn’t spin?

It’s jammed. Unplug it, free the plate with a quarter-inch Allen wrench in the hex socket on the bottom, remove whatever jammed it with tongs, press the reset button, and try again.

Why does water back up into the other side of my double sink?

The clog is past the disposal, in the shared drain pipe or the trap under the sink. The disposal is pushing water at a blockage and it’s coming up the easiest path, which is the other bowl. That’s a drain cleaning, not a disposal problem.

Does my disposal need repair or replacement?

Leaks at the top flange or the side hoses, a jam, or a worn splash guard are repairs. A leak from the bottom of the unit, a motor that trips constantly, or a unit past 10 years with any of those symptoms is a replacement.

Can I put ice down the disposal?

Yes, and you should. Ice and coarse salt once a month cleans the grind chamber better than anything you can buy.

Garbage disposal repair and replacement on the North Shore

Biagi Plumbing has been keeping North Shore kitchens draining since 1989, in Wilmette, Winnetka, Glencoe, Highland Park, Lake Forest, Lake Bluff, Northbrook, Glenview, Evanston, Deerfield, Buffalo Grove, Libertyville, and the surrounding communities.

If your disposal is leaking from the bottom, won’t reset, or the sink keeps backing up no matter what you do, call Biagi Plumbing at (847) 512-8921. We’ll fix the unit if it’s worth fixing, replace it with one sized for your kitchen if it isn’t, and clear the drain line if that’s the real problem.

Contact Us

By checking this box and signing up for texts, you agree to receive informational messages (appointment reminders, account notifications, marketing and promotional messages such as sales, coupons, seasonal deals, etc.) from Biagi Plumbing Corporation at the number provided. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Unsubscribe anytime by replying STOP. Reply HELP for help or email us at [email protected]. Learn more on our Privacy Policy & Terms & Conditions

Schedule Now

By checking this box and signing up for texts, you agree to receive informational messages (appointment reminders, account notifications, marketing and promotional messages such as sales, coupons, seasonal deals, etc.) from Biagi Plumbing Corporation at the number provided. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency varies. Unsubscribe anytime by replying STOP. Reply HELP for help or email us at [email protected]. Learn more on our Privacy Policy & Terms & Conditions

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Notice

At Biagi Plumbing, we are committed to ensuring that individuals with disabilities enjoy full access to our websites. In recognition of this commitment, we are in the process of making modifications to increase the accessibility and usability of this website, using the relevant portions of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0 (WCAG 2.0) as our standard. Please be aware that our efforts are ongoing. If at any time you have difficulty using this website or with a particular web page or function on this site, please contact us by phone at (847) 512-8921; or email us at ([email protected]) and place “Web Content Accessibility (ADA)” in the subject heading and we will make all reasonable efforts to assist you.